Every year the three Marvin sisters — single mother Megan (Erin Cahill), practical lawyer Bethany (Rachel Rhodes-Devey), and passionate and conniving Mary — return home for Christmas together at their beloved childhood home in Vermont. And while they couldn’t be any different from one another, they all agree on one thing: there’s nothing more magical than spending Christmas together with their parents Peggy (Ann Osmond) and John.

Unfortunately, this legacy is coming to an end, Peggy and John are selling the house, and their buyer is Megan’s hunky high school sweetheart Nash (Justin Bruening). As she spends more time with Nash, Megan realizes that she could be falling in love again, with the very man poised to undo the memories she’s so desperate to protect.